"There is no Buddha magic": what if you were right?

"There is no Buddha magic": what if you were right?

I am sometimes reproached with two points: "The Buddha never taught magic" and "He never asked his disciples to wear amulets."

On this point, I agree. I am not going to invent a word of the Buddha to defend a tradition that I love. Wearing an amulet is not a condition for following the Buddha's teachings, and no amulet replaces practice, mindfulness, or compassion.

But another question deserves to be asked: did the history of Buddhism stop with the Buddha?

For about 2,500 years, his teachings have crossed countries, encountered cultures, and been transmitted by countless masters. New ways of praying, representing, meditating, and witnessing one's faith have developed. A Tibetan thangka, a mantra, or a Thai amulet are not necessarily objects that the historical Buddha would have used or prescribed. Yet they belong to the living history of Buddhist communities.

For example, the word "mantra" does not even appear in the Dhammapada.
Should we conclude from this that Buddhist traditions that practice mantras, notably Vajrayāna, are not Buddhist? Of course not. The Dhammapada is a fundamental text, but it is not an inventory of everything that Buddhists have practiced and transmitted over the centuries. Why apply a criterion to amulets that one would not apply to mantras?

Since the Buddha meditated under a tree, I see the Dharma as a tree that has grown and flourished over the centuries.

At the start, there is a seed (the Buddha and his teaching). Then come the roots, the trunk, and the branches (the Sangha), the flowers (the Buddhist traditions), and the fruits (the awakened Masters).

One can bite into an apple, make a pie, or make cider.
No one claims that cider was already in the seed in the form of a bottle! Yet, without that seed and without the tree that grew, it would not exist.

It is the same with Buddhist traditions. Recognizing their roots does not oblige us to pass off every branch as an original word of the Buddha. And recognizing that some branches appeared later does not mean that they did not grow on this tree.

This does not mean either that everything that claims to be Buddhist is good. One can discuss a practice, criticize a belief, or reject extravagant promises. The ancient texts themselves place limits on the practices of divination or magic performed by monks. The Buddha described divination and magic as "minor arts, inferior to the Dharma." He did not say that divination and magic were bad things or "abominations," he said "minor arts."
A minor art remains an art, doesn't it?

This discussion deserves better than a simple "the historical Buddha did not teach it, therefore it does not exist in Buddhism."

When I speak of the "Magic of the Buddha," I am talking about these traditions, these objects, and the place they have taken in the lives of people and temples, particularly in Thailand and Tibet.
I am not saying that owning an amulet is enough to practice the Dharma. I am simply saying that, for many people, it can be a tangible link to a master, a blessing, an intention, or a teaching.

One can prefer to return to the seed and let it dry out.
For my part, I also like to look at the tree that has grown, its flowers, and its fruits.

Share this post...

Previous post Next post

Comments

Leave a comment